[DSRP Evidence](https://dsrpevidence.org/)

# 'Wicked Problems' Arise When People Misunderstand Water Issues

## Details

**Authors** Solin, Jeremy

**Year** 2017

**Publisher** WisContext (PBS Wisconsin)

**Kind of work** press

**Discipline** Environment & Sustainability

**Secondary disciplines** Education, Hydrology

**Kind of engagement** public

**Applied** false

[Read it](https://pbswisconsin.org/news-item/wicked-problems-arise-when-people-misunderstand-water-issues/)

## In authors' words

### What they set out to do (purpose)

To ask why Wisconsin's water problems persist despite extensive attention and available information, and to argue that the missing ingredient is structured thinking rather than more data — with cognitive science presented as being as important to water challenges as aquatic science.

### How they did it (methods)

A public-affairs article by the coordinator of the Wisconsin Water Thinkers Network. It surveys current Wisconsin water controversies, argues that information alone does not change behavior, introduces ThinkWater and its DSRP basis, and then works the four patterns through one case: elevated nitrate levels in groundwater.

### What they found (results)

The author concludes that wicked water problems arise from a mismatch between how water systems actually work and how people think they work, quoting Cabrera to that effect, and that building knowledge rather than distributing information requires teaching people to make distinctions, organize systems, recognize relationships, and take perspectives. He reports that ThinkWater's aim is to bring this into water education and outreach.

## Commentary

### In short

A water-education article that diagnoses Wisconsin's water problems as a thinking problem and then works DSRP through a single case, elevated nitrate levels in groundwater.

### In more detail

Solin opens with the water issues then in front of Wisconsin communities — lead in Milwaukee, algal blooms, groundwater quantity, bacterial contamination in the northeast, high-capacity well rules in the Central Sands, and nitrates in rural private wells — and asks why the problems keep growing while information about them accumulates. His answer is that information is not knowledge: people have to think with information before it becomes usable, and cognitive science can say what that thinking consists of. He introduces ThinkWater, a USDA-supported national water education campaign then based at University of Wisconsin-Extension, and the Wisconsin ThinkWater School, which had trained teams working on stormwater, water quality monitoring, watershed planning, groundwater contamination, water as a common resource, surface water nutrients, and soil health. DSRP is named as the method the campaign uses, credited to Derek Cabrera, and Cabrera is quoted on wicked problems as a mismatch between real systems and mental ones. The article then runs all four patterns through nitrates in groundwater. Distinctions separate groundwater from surface water and precipitation, nitrates from other chemicals, and elevated concentrations from common ones. Systems list the parts of the nitrate system — soils, fertilizer, manure, rain and snow, bedrock, septic systems — and place that system inside agricultural, economic, geologic, and community systems. Relationships note that these parts are linked to one another and that each link carries part of the explanation. Perspectives contrast the fertilizer manufacturer, for whom the product is a sale, the farmer, for whom it is a cost and leaching is waste, and the person drinking the water, for whom it is a health question.

### Response

The article does the thing most short treatments of DSRP skip: it picks one real system and takes all four patterns through it, so a reader sees the rules doing work rather than being listed. The nesting is handled correctly — the groundwater nitrate system is shown as a part of agricultural, economic, geologic, and community systems rather than as a closed box — and the perspectives section is the strongest, because it identifies vantages that reorganize the same facts into different problems instead of offering viewpoints as opinions to be respected. Two points are loose. The relationships section asserts that the parts are connected and that each connection matters, but names no action-reaction pair, so the pattern that carries the causal content of the nitrate story is the one left least specified. And the closing description of DSRP as helping "simplify complex systems into components that can inform workable solutions" understates the claim: the four patterns are an account of how information gets structured, and applying them to a nitrate problem adds boundaries, levels, couplings, and vantages that were not explicit before. That is not simplification.

**Patterns it shows** D, S, R, P

**Added** 2026-11-19

**How to cite this** Solin, Jeremy (2017). 'Wicked Problems' Arise When People Misunderstand Water Issues. WisContext (PBS Wisconsin).
