[DSRP Evidence](https://dsrpevidence.org/)

# Quantum mechanics and the covariance of physical laws in quantum reference frames

## Details

**Authors** Giacomini, Flaminia and Castro-Ruiz, Esteban and Brukner, Časlav

**Year** 2019

**Publisher** Nature Communications

**Kind of work** article

**Discipline** Physics

**Applied** false

[Read it at the publisher](https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-018-08155-0) 
10.1038/s41467-018-08155-0

## In authors' words

### Abstract

In physics, every observation is made with respect to a frame of reference. Although reference frames are usually not considered as degrees of freedom, in all practical situations it is a physical system which constitutes a reference frame. Can a quantum system be considered as a reference frame and, if so, which description would it give of the world? Here, we introduce a general method to quantise reference frame transformations, which generalises the usual reference frame transformation to a “superposition of coordinate transformations”. We describe states, measurement, and dynamical evolution in different quantum reference frames, without appealing to an external, absolute reference frame, and find that entanglement and superposition are frame-dependent features. The transformation also leads to a generalisation of the notion of covariance of dynamical physical laws, to an extension of the weak equivalence principle, and to the possibility of defining the rest frame of a quantum system.

### What they set out to do (purpose)

To ask whether a quantum system can serve as a reference frame and what description of the world it would give, and to develop a general method for transforming between quantum reference frames without appeal to an external, absolute frame.

### Who or what was studied (sample)

No empirical sample. Theoretical work in non-relativistic (Galilean) quantum mechanics, with worked examples of three-system arrangements, an atom-photon application, and a measurement scheme.

### How they did it (methods)

The authors construct unitary canonical transformations between reference frames attached to quantum systems, generalizing spatial translations, Galilean boosts and uniformly accelerated frames to superpositions of these. They derive the Schrödinger equation as seen from a quantum reference frame, define symmetry transformations between frames, and work examples showing how states, dynamics and measurements change under a change of frame. Calculations are done in one dimension.

### What they found (results)

Quantum states and their features, including superposition and entanglement, are defined only relative to a chosen reference frame: a system that is well localized for one observer can be in superposition, or entangled with the first observer, for another. Measured probabilities are invariant under the transformations, but the observers disagree about which systems and which observables are measured. The authors extend covariance of physical laws to superpositions of translations and boosts, extend the weak equivalence principle to a frame in a superposition of accelerations, and define the rest frame of a quantum system in a superposition of momenta. They also find that a change to a quantum reference frame is not uniquely defined until a choice of relative variables is made.

## Commentary

### In short

Physicists worked out how to describe the world from the standpoint of a quantum particle rather than a classical laboratory. They found that whether something is in superposition or entangled depends on which system is treated as the reference frame.

### In more detail

The paper treats a reference frame as a physical system with its own quantum state rather than as an ideal abstraction standing outside the physics. With three systems, an initial frame C, a new frame A and an observed system B, the authors build transformations that carry the description from C's standpoint to A's and back, with no absolute frame needed. In their examples, if A is in a superposition of two positions as seen from C, then from A's standpoint B and C are entangled; if A and B are perfectly correlated as seen from C, then from A's standpoint B is sharply located while C is in superposition. The two observers agree on probabilities but disagree on which systems are measured and which observable is measured. The authors show that a frame does not appear as a dynamical degree of freedom in its own description, that a change of frame requires first choosing which relative variables to use, and that the weak equivalence principle carries over to a frame in a superposition of accelerations. An application computes the photon state needed to excite an atom moving in a superposition of velocities by moving to the atom's rest frame and back.

### Response

This is a strong instance of P. Properties normally taken as intrinsic to a quantum state, superposition and entanglement, turn out to depend on the system from which the world is described, and each frame describes the others as objects while excluding itself, which matches the point-and-view structure of the perspective pattern. R carries real weight because the formalism is built entirely from relative variables between systems, and entanglement is itself a relation that appears or disappears with the choice of frame. Caveats: the work is formal and non-relativistic, with no experimental test yet; the frames are physical reference systems, not cognitive observers, so the match to P is structural rather than psychological; and the finding that relative variables must be chosen before a frame change is defined could be read as a question of what is distinguished as the system, a D issue the DSRP mapping does not settle. Composite frames appear but S is not central.

**Patterns it shows** R, P

Formal proof or model

**Added** 2026-11-19

**How to cite this** Giacomini, Flaminia and Castro-Ruiz, Esteban and Brukner, Časlav (2019). Quantum mechanics and the covariance of physical laws in quantum reference frames. Nature Communications.
