Living Evidence Compendium

The Universal & Atomic Elements of Organization

A falsifiable scientific theory proposing that the same irreducible structures organize both thought and reality — from the quantum to the social scale.

What if the same structures that organize your thoughts also organize the world? Explore the hypothesis

O-Theory proposes that four irreducible structures — Distinctions, Systems, Relationships and Perspectives (DSRP) — form the universal grammar of organization. Rather than being merely useful ways of thinking, these structures are hypothesized to be the atomic elements from which every organized phenomenon emerges, whether in cognition, biology, physics, mathematics, society, or the cosmos.

DS RP
DistinctionsSystemsRelationshipsPerspectives
Identity ↔ OtherPart ↔ Whole Action ↔ ReactionPoint ↔ View
D := (i ↔ o)S := (p ↔ w) R := (a ↔ r)P := (ṗ ↔ v)

This is a living scientific evidence compendium: an open, continually evolving collection of independent empirical research, formal theory, mathematical proofs, cross-disciplinary analyses, applications, critiques, and proposed falsifications. Every entry is included because it supports, refines, challenges, or attempts to falsify the theory.

Scientific theories are strengthened not only by evidence that confirms their predictions, but also by surviving attempts to falsify them. This compendium brings both together: independent evidence from researchers who were not testing DSRP and counterexample candidates evaluated against the formal theory.

One counterexample is enough to falsify O-Theory. Until then, the question remains: do the same four structures organize everything from quantum systems to human thought?

Try a demonstration yourself Why is this convergent evidence compelling? See why independent convergence is one of science’s strongest forms of evidence.

independent opportunities for the theory to fail.

Independent convergence is one of the strongest forms of scientific evidence because researchers arrive at the same conclusion while investigating different questions for different reasons.

The number is not the point. Researchers in different fields, studying different questions with different methods, repeatedly arrived at the same structural predictions—almost always without testing DSRP or using its language.

Discipline
Field

No studies match your search

Try a different term or clear the filters.

About this collection

This compendium began as the peer-reviewed literature review “A Literature Review of the Universal and Atomic Elements of Complex Cognition,” published in the Journal of Systems Thinking with 109 studies. That paper is the peer-reviewed foundation. What you see here is its living, continuously updated version . New studies are checked before they are added, and the collection now holds and keeps growing. Open any card to see what the researchers found, why it bears on DSRP, and where the original review discusses it, the fuller account.

Cabrera, D., Cabrera, L., & Cabrera, E. A Literature Review of the Universal and Atomic Elements of Complex Cognition. Journal of Systems Thinking. · Cornell University & Cabrera Research Lab.

How to cite this collection

APA
BibTeX

The collection is updated continuously, so the citation carries the date you consulted it rather than a study count — the count changes weekly, and putting it in the reference would make the same collection look like a different work to everyone who cites it. To cite a single claim or study, use its own address: every one has a permanent link.

About this record

This is the adversarial half of the compendium. Where the evidence track asks what converges on DSRP, this one asks what would end it: a single organized phenomenon whose structure needs a fifth pattern, a ninth element, or a fifth structural dynamic. It holds written up from candidates across territories, and corollaries — the general answers those cases settle against. Every case is published whether it held or failed, including the ones still open.

How to cite the counterexample candidates and corollaries

APA
BibTeX

Cite this rather than the evidence collection when the point is what survived attack. The two are separate works with separate addresses: one asks what converges on the theory, the other asks what would end it, and a reference to the first does not support a claim about the second. Case and resolution numbers change when the record is revised, so cite a case by its own permanent link rather than by number.

Know of work that belongs here?

This collection is meant to keep growing. Send us a study, paper, book or critique that bears on DSRP, whether it supports the theory or cuts against it, and we will read it and decide whether it belongs.

 

DSRP Evidence

Lifting the veil on Bohm's holomovement

Details

Authors Andrew Lohrey, Bruce Boreham

Year 2021

Publisher National Library of Medicine

Kind of work article

Discipline Philosophy

Secondary disciplines Physics, Biology

Reading level intermediate

Applied false

Read it at the publisher 10.1080/19420889.2021.2001157

In authors' words

Abstract

In this paper, we argue that Bohm's unbroken and undivided totality he called the holomovement, the title he gave to the concept of the self-organizing universe, is more coherently understood when viewed as universal consciousness. Bohm's understanding of consciousness oscillates around being a quality of local minds and the interconnected totality of the holomovement. We suggest such equivocations impose limitations on Bohm's general holistic framework because they import into his model the limiting restrictions of Cartesian separation and are, therefore, incongruous for use within his holistic model of the holomovement. We also argue that the term 'meaning' has a structural and functional agency appropriate to Bohm's model of the holomovement, while also reflecting the living characteristics of this organic totality that is full of meaning.

What they set out to do (purpose)

To ask whether the veil of reductionism has been fully lifted from David Bohm's model of wholeness, and to argue that Bohm's holomovement is more coherently understood as universal consciousness whose content is implicit meaning.

Who or what was studied (sample)

The published writings of David Bohm and Basil Hiley on wholeness, the implicate and explicate orders, meaning and consciousness, chiefly Wholeness and the Implicate Order, The Undivided Universe, Unfolding Meaning, and Hiley's 2008 paper on process and the implicate order.

How they did it (methods)

Conceptual and textual analysis. The authors trace what Bohm and Hiley say about wholeness, meaning and consciousness, identify where Bohm's position on consciousness shifts between panpsychist, dual-aspect and conventional reductionist views, and read the implicate and explicate orders through the authors' own theory of implicit and explicit meaning.

What they found (results)

The authors conclude that Bohm's hologram model describes symmetrical whole-to-part and part-to-whole relations in which each part is both a part and an instance of the whole, and that the holomovement must be a single system containing nested subsystems. They argue that the implicate and explicate orders rest on implicit and explicit meaning, that implicit meaning is characterized by context, unity, interconnection and implication, and that the explicit differences of the explicate order unfold out of implicit context. Because Bohm sometimes confines consciousness to the local mind, they find his framework carries a residue of Cartesian separation; removing it, they argue, makes the holomovement universal consciousness filled with implicit meaning. They extend this to biology, arguing that symbiosis-centered accounts of evolution follow from the unifying implicate order, while competition-centered accounts follow from an exclusive focus on explicit differences.

Commentary

In short

Lohrey and Boreham reread David Bohm's theory of wholeness and argue that his ``holomovement,'' the undivided totality from which all forms unfold, is best understood as universal consciousness made of meaning. They find Bohm wavering on whether consciousness is local or universal, and argue the wavering lets back in the very Cartesian split his theory was built to remove.

In more detail

The paper starts from Basil Hiley's question of whether Bohm's model of wholeness has lifted the veil of reductionism far enough. The authors first lay out Bohm's two supports for wholeness. One is the hologram: illuminate any fragment of the plate and the whole image appears, less sharply, so each fragment is both a part of the whole and an instance of it. The other is Bohm's theory of the implicate order, an enfolded and undivided whole, and the explicate order of separate objects in space and time that unfolds from it. Following Hiley, they take wholeness to mean that the parts are determined by the order of the whole rather than the reverse, and they argue that a coherent holomovement must be one over-riding system containing nested subsystems. The authors then argue that Bohm's terms implicate and explicate derive from implicit and explicit meaning, and they draw on Bohm's later book Unfolding Meaning, where he suggests meaning can enfold both matter and energy and is more fundamental than either. Their own theory of meaning treats implicit meaning as context, unity, interconnection and implication, and explicit meaning as the local differences that unfold from that context and fold back into it, as thoughts do. The central criticism is that Bohm's treatment of consciousness oscillates between panpsychist, dual-aspect and conventional positions, and in several passages places consciousness in the individual mind. The authors argue that this local reading imports Cartesian separation into a model meant to have none, and that following Bohm's own statements about meaning through to their implications makes the holomovement universal consciousness. They also apply the argument to evolutionary biology, contrasting Margulis's symbiosis-centered account with competition-centered Darwinism and tying the difference to which of Bohm's two orders a worldview treats as primary. The paper is an interpretive argument rather than an empirical study or a formal derivation.

Response

The paper's strongest point of contact with DSRP is part-whole structure. The authors describe the hologram as a system in which every part is also an instance of the whole, insist that the holomovement is one system of nested subsystems, and adopt Hiley's definition of wholeness as the whole determining the parts. That is the Systems pattern stated in their own terms, arrived at from Bohm's physics and a theory of meaning rather than from cognitive science. A second point is the relation between implicit context and explicit difference: explicit meanings and objects unfold as distinctions against an implicit background and fold back into it, which tracks the identity-other and figure-ground character of Distinctions. The authors also treat context dependence as crucial, which touches Perspectives, but they never describe a point and view or an observer's vantage changing what is seen, so that pattern is not recorded here. The caveats are serious. This is a philosophical reinterpretation of Bohm, not an empirical finding or a formal model, so it shows that a careful reader of Bohm lands on part-whole nesting and figure-ground structure, not that those structures are present in nature. The authors' larger conclusions, that meaning is the fundamental ground of the universe and that the holomovement is universal consciousness, go well beyond anything DSRP claims and should not be read as support for it. The evolutionary argument is asserted rather than tested.

Patterns it shows D, S, R, P

Added 2026-11-22

How to cite this Andrew Lohrey, Bruce Boreham (2021). Lifting the veil on Bohm's holomovement. National Library of Medicine.