[DSRP Evidence](https://dsrpevidence.org/)

# Some Major Theoretical Problems concerning the Concept of Hierarchy in the Analysis of Tonal Music

## Details

**Authors** Narmour, Eugene

**Year** 1983

**Publisher** Music Perception

**Kind of work** article

**Discipline** Music Theory

**Secondary disciplines** Cognitive Science

**Applied** false

[Read it at the publisher](https://doi.org/10.2307/40285255) 
10.2307/40285255

## In authors' words

### What they set out to do (purpose)

To examine whether level-analysis in music theory is truly hierarchical and to propose a theory that can capture an individual work's unique structure.

### Who or what was studied (sample)

The theme of Mozart's Piano Sonata K. 331, contrasted with analyses by DeVoto, Lester, Schenker, and Meyer.

### How they did it (methods)

A hypothetical theory built on the cognitive concepts of return, reversal, and continuation (similarity), applied to melody, harmony, and duration.

### What they found (results)

Contemporary level-analysis is rarely hierarchical in the strict sense. Treating closure and nonclosure as simultaneous at every hierarchical level yields both network and tree relationships, horizontal and vertical structure, and transient levels. In the Mozart theme, hierarchical analysis gives way to a synthesis in which the melody's levels appear as rankings of pitch on a single level.

## Commentary

### In short

Narmour argues that musical levels are not strictly nested and shows, on a Mozart theme, how relations of return, reversal, and continuation produce structure that trees alone cannot capture.

### Response

The paper concerns levels and wholes in music (S) and builds its alternative on similarity relations among musical events (R). It also shows part-whole structure that is not a clean tree, which is a useful qualification for systems claims. Perspective is plausible (several analysts read the same theme differently) but was not established from what was read. Based on the abstract and publisher page; no DOI check beyond Crossref.

**Patterns it shows** S, R

**Added** 2026-11-07

**How to cite this** Narmour, Eugene (1983). Some Major Theoretical Problems concerning the Concept of Hierarchy in the Analysis of Tonal Music. Music Perception.
