[DSRP Evidence](https://dsrpevidence.org/)

# Moons are planets: Scientific usefulness versus cultural teleology in the taxonomy of planetary science

## Details

**Authors** Metzger, Philip T. and Grundy, W.M. and Sykes, Mark V. and Stern, Alan and Bell III, James F. and Detelich, Charlene E. and Runyon, Kirby and Summers, Michael

**Year** 2022

**Publisher** Icarus

**Kind of work** article

**Discipline** Astronomy

**Secondary disciplines** History, Philosophy

**Applied** false

[Read it at the publisher](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.icarus.2021.114768) 
10.1016/j.icarus.2021.114768

## In authors' words

### What they set out to do (purpose)

To argue, from the history of the term, that moons belong in the class "planet" and that planetary taxonomy should rest on scientific usefulness rather than inherited cultural concepts.

### Who or what was studied (sample)

Historical record of how the term planet was used from the Copernican period through the 1920s and after, and the 2006 IAU definition.

### How they did it (methods)

Historical and conceptual analysis of classification criteria.

### What they found (results)

The authors find that from the Copernican era through the 1920s planets were defined by intrinsic physical traits, with moons counted as planets and primary versus secondary status a lower subdivision. They trace the orbit-based boundary to a nineteenth-century folk taxonomy and argue that it has no scientific basis, that the 2006 IAU definition mixes dynamical and intrinsic criteria, and that classes should align with explanatory theory such as geological complexity.

## Commentary

### In short

A historical and conceptual study arguing that the category "planet" should be drawn by what bodies are like, not what they orbit, so that moons count as planets.

### Response

The argument is about where the boundary of a category falls and what criterion draws it (D), with primary and secondary bodies nested as subclasses inside a larger class (S). The authors also state that taxonomy is theory-laden and purpose-driven and contrast scientific and cultural vantage points (P). Relationships are only weakly present (tidal effects are discussed and set aside as a class boundary). The paper is a position paper, so the evidence is conceptual and the authors' own preference is part of the claim. Only the first 100,000 characters of the text were read.

**Patterns it shows** D, S, P

Shows the structure is there

**Added** 2026-11-08

**How to cite this** Metzger, Philip T. and Grundy, W.M. and Sykes, Mark V. and Stern, Alan and Bell III, James F. and Detelich, Charlene E. and Runyon, Kirby and Summers, Michael (2022). Moons are planets: Scientific usefulness versus cultural teleology in the taxonomy of planetary science. Icarus.
