[DSRP Evidence](https://dsrpevidence.org/)

# Property Rules, Liability Rules, and Inalienability: One View of the Cathedral

## Details

**Authors** Calabresi, Guido and Melamed, A. Douglas

**Year** 1972

**Publisher** Harvard Law Review

**Kind of work** article

**Discipline** Law & Jurisprudence

**Secondary disciplines** Economics

**Applied** false

[Read it at the publisher](https://doi.org/10.2307/1340059) 
10.2307/1340059

## In authors' words

### What they set out to do (purpose)

To develop a framework for legal analysis that integrates legal relationships traditionally analyzed in separate subject areas such as property and torts.

### How they did it (methods)

A conceptual analysis built on the notion of entitlements, applied to problems such as pollution. It asks in what circumstances a particular entitlement should be granted, and in what circumstances it should be protected by a property rule, a liability rule or an inalienability rule.

### What they found (results)

The authors distinguish three ways a legal entitlement can be protected. Under a property rule, the entitlement can be taken only through a voluntary transaction at a price the holder agrees to. Under a liability rule, someone may take it if he pays an objectively determined value. Under an inalienability rule, transfer is restricted, which also limits the grant of the entitlement itself. They show that one entitlement, a homeowner's house, can be protected by each of the three depending on the situation: a purchase, a taking by eminent domain, or a sale by someone who is drunk or incompetent. They describe the article as one view among several of the same subject.

## Commentary

### In short

A legal framework that sorts the ways a right can be protected into three kinds, according to whether it can be taken only by consent, taken on payment of a set price, or not transferred at all.

### Response

The framework is built on a distinction among three forms of protection for an entitlement, which is the strongest fit (distinctions). Each form is defined by the relationship between the holder and the party who wants the entitlement: buyer and seller, owner and state, injurer and victim (relationships). Perspectives is arguable and is not claimed: the authors call the article one view of a subject that needs several views, but the framework itself does not model viewpoint. Later legal scholars dispute how useful the property-rule and liability-rule distinction is in practice, which limits how much weight the distinctions fit should carry. The work is an analytic framework and is not tested empirically.

**Patterns it shows** D, R

**Added** 2026-11-17

**How to cite this** Calabresi, Guido and Melamed, A. Douglas (1972). Property Rules, Liability Rules, and Inalienability: One View of the Cathedral. Harvard Law Review.
