[DSRP Evidence](https://dsrpevidence.org/)

# What is a gene, post-ENCODE? History and updated definition

## Details

**Authors** Gerstein, Mark B. and Bruce, Can and Rozowsky, Joel S. and Zheng, Deyou and Du, Jiang and Korbel, Jan O. and Emanuelsson, Olof and Zhang, Zhengdong D. and Weissman, Sherman and Snyder, Michael

**Year** 2007

**Publisher** Genome Research

**Kind of work** article

**Discipline** Genetics

**Applied** false

[Read it at the publisher](https://doi.org/10.1101/gr.6339607) 
10.1101/gr.6339607

## In authors' words

### Abstract

While sequencing of the human genome surprised us with how many protein-coding genes there are, it did not fundamentally change our perspective on what a gene is. In contrast, the complex patterns of dispersed regulation and pervasive transcription uncovered by the ENCODE project, together with non-genic conservation and the abundance of noncoding RNA genes, have challenged the notion of the gene. To illustrate this, we review the evolution of operational definitions of a gene over the past century—from the abstract elements of heredity of Mendel and Morgan to the present-day ORFs enumerated in the sequence databanks. We then summarize the current ENCODE findings and provide a computational metaphor for the complexity. Finally, we propose a tentative update to the definition of a gene: A gene is a union of genomic sequences encoding a coherent set of potentially overlapping functional products. Our definition sidesteps the complexities of regulation and transcription by removing the former altogether from the definition and arguing that final, functional gene products (rather than intermediate transcripts) should be used to group together entities associated with a single gene. It also manifests how integral the concept of biological function is in defining genes.

### What they set out to do (purpose)

To review how operational definitions of the gene have changed over the past century, to summarize ENCODE findings that challenge the gene concept, and to propose an updated definition.

### Who or what was studied (sample)

Operational definitions of the gene from Mendel and Morgan to the open reading frames listed in sequence databanks, and the findings of the ENCODE project.

### How they did it (methods)

A historical review of gene definitions, a summary of ENCODE findings, and a proposed definition illustrated with a computational metaphor.

### What they found (results)

The authors find that dispersed regulation, pervasive transcription, non-genic conservation and the abundance of noncoding RNA genes have challenged the notion of the gene. They propose that a gene is a union of genomic sequences encoding a coherent set of potentially overlapping functional products. Under this definition regulation is left out, and final functional products, not intermediate transcripts, are what group entities into a single gene.

## Commentary

### In short

The paper traces how the gene has been defined over the past century and shows why large-scale genome data strain those definitions. It proposes defining a gene as a set of genomic sequences that together encode a coherent group of functional products.

### Response

The proposed definition draws a boundary around the gene, and it does so by choosing a criterion: grouping by final functional product places regulation and intermediate transcripts outside, and sequences that serve the same products inside (distinctions). The definition also describes a gene as a whole made of parts, a union of genomic sequences that may overlap, so one stretch of sequence can belong to more than one gene (systems). The fit to relationships is partial. The authors acknowledge dispersed regulation but remove it from the definition to avoid its complexity, so coupling between elements is recognized without being built into the definition. The paper's contribution is a definitional proposal, so the fit to distinctions and systems reflects a design choice about how to draw the boundary and not a measured property of genomes. This assessment rests on the abstract.

**Patterns it shows** D, S

Shows the structure is there

**Added** 2026-11-17

**How to cite this** Gerstein, Mark B. and Bruce, Can and Rozowsky, Joel S. and Zheng, Deyou and Du, Jiang and Korbel, Jan O. and Emanuelsson, Olof and Zhang, Zhengdong D. and Weissman, Sherman and Snyder, Michael (2007). What is a gene, post-ENCODE? History and updated definition. Genome Research.
